One of the best sensible gentle switches and dimmers: Lighting is the inspiration of the sensible residence

No sensible lighting answer is as elegant as having sensible gentle switches and dimmers embedded in your partitions. Certain, you might screw sensible bulbs into your fixtures, or plug a few lamps into sensible plugs and name it a day, but when the sunshine fixture in query is managed by a dumb swap, you’ll by no means be capable to management that sensible bulb if the swap is within the off place.

Whereas they could be a ache to put in—rent an electrician in the event you not comfy doing it your self—as soon as it’s put in, a sensible gentle swap enables you to flip your lights on and off in accordance with a schedule, with a smartphone app, and—with the set up of equipment—in response to voice instructions, movement, and even your location (offered you’ve your smartphone with you).

Up to date on July 29, 2021 with our evaluate of the second-gen Philips Hue Dimmer Swap from Signify. Not solely does the brand new Dimmer Swap look extra modern than its predecessor, it additionally provides a brand new Hue button and a time-based gentle scene mode, together with a bigger wall plate that permits for each peel-and-stick in addition to screw mounting.

The place a sensible swap merely turns a related gentle bulb or fixture on and off, a sensible dimmer may also regulate the brightness of the bulbs within the fixtures it controls. Since a dimmer is actually a swap with an added perform, we’ll use the phrases interchangeably right here, however our critiques focus totally on dimmers. We’ll focus on the distinction in additional element within the patrons’ information on the following web page.

The costs of sensible switches and dimmers have come down so much up to now yr or two, though the fanciest and strongest examples stay costly. You’ll encounter merchandise from acquainted names comparable to Leviton and Lutron, in addition to a bunch of newcomers to this area, together with Midday and Hogar. In most circumstances, changing a dumb swap with a sensible one is a comparatively easy DIY mission; however once more, there’s no disgrace in hiring an electrician to do the job.

Listed below are our prime picks in sensible dimmers, adopted by a information to the options and terminology you’ll encounter if you store for one. You can even go straight to a listing of our most up-to-date smart-switch critiques.

Greatest sensible dimmer total

Lutron’s Caséta ecosystem is way much less open than the opposite large three sensible lighting platforms: Wi-Fi, Z-Wave, and Zigbee. Lutron is the one supply of dimmers and switches, however the firm is nice about supporting different lessons of third-party merchandise inside the Caséta ecosystem. Along with its personal line of motorized sensible shades, ceiling fan controllers, plug-in units, occupancy sensors, and distant controls, you too can create time- and location-based sensible residence “scenes” incorporating any Caséta or Serena product together with Sonos audio system, a number of manufacturers of sensible thermostats, and Hunter ceiling followers. The Caséta Sensible Bridge is Apple HomeKit suitable, too, and it may be built-in with a Samsung SmartThings hub.

The dimmer switches within the Lutron Caséta Sensible Lighting Dimmer Swap Equipment are elegantly designed with 4 plate-style buttons: On on the prime, off on the backside, and triangular brighten and dim buttons within the center. A stack of LEDs on the left-hand aspect signifies the brightness stage. The equipment additionally comes with Lutron’s Pico wi-fi distant controls, for these conditions the place you don’t wish to bark at a sensible speaker to dim the lights. The Caséta dimmer can also be perfect for installations the place there is no such thing as a impartial wire within the field—it’s one of many few sensible switches that doesn’t require one.

Greatest Wi-Fi sensible dimmer

GE doesn’t construct the prettiest dimmer in the marketplace, however its C-Begin Sensible Swap Movement Sensing+Dimmer swap positive packs the options. And in the event you occur to personal C by GE sensible bulbs, the swap may also management them even when they’re not wired to the dimmer. Being a Wi-Fi gadget, this dimmer swap doesn’t require the presence of a sensible residence hub or some other bridge to your private home community. An onboard movement sensor can flip the sunshine swap on when the room is occupied, and an ambient gentle sensor will cease that from taking place if there’s sufficient daylight that the additional gentle isn’t wanted. There’s additionally night time gentle within the type of a hoop across the on/off button, however that may be turned off within the app in the event you discover that provides to your indoor gentle air pollution. There’s now additionally a 3-wire model of this product that doesn’t require a impartial wire

Greatest Zigbee sensible dimmer

In the event you’ve settled on Zigbee as your sensible lighting protocol of selection—and it’s actually not a foul one, contemplating the one different factor you’ll want is an Amazon Echo Plus sensible speaker—permit us to advocate Jasco’s Enbrighten Zigbee In-Wall Sensible Dimmer. This in-wall dimmer not solely has a slimline design that isn’t robust to shove again into the field if you set up it, it has sufficient onboard intelligence to differentiate the road wire from the load wire, so that you don’t want to fret about mixing them up in the event you’re doing the work for your self. This sensible dimmer is affordably priced, too.

Greatest Z-Wave sensible dimmer

Placing this roundup collectively uncovered a gap in our editorial protection. I’ve had Leviton’s Decora Sensible Z-Wave switches and dimmers (together with different manufacturers of Z-Wave switches) put in in my very own sensible residence for a few years (we constructed the home in 2007), however we’ve by no means formally reviewed them. That stated, Leviton’s Z-Wave lighting controls are amongst my favorites; so, whereas TechHive hasn’t formally reviewed Leviton’s product, I’ve deep private expertise with it and advocate it strongly.

Most subtle sensible dimmer

Sadly, our present favourite sensible lighting system of all time just isn’t solely very costly, it’s additionally now accessible solely via skilled installers after the corporate was acquired by Racepoint Vitality. However in the event you can afford it, that is probably the most subtle—and probably the most stunning—in-wall lighting in the marketplace. The system consists of a Room Director dimmer with a coloration OLED touchscreen show that replaces a major swap in a room, and as much as 10 barely extra ordinary-looking (they don’t have shows) Extension switches. You possibly can construct a number of lighting scenes with this method that may activate each gentle within the room at a preset brightness stage primarily based on the temper you want to set. Learn our in-depth evaluate to be taught extra about this ultra-sophisticated residence lighting answer.


Good predated Midday in integrating a contact panel with a sensible swap, and this sensible dimmer has some very cool tips up its sleeve, starting from with the ability to stream video from a doorbell digital camera to controlling a Sonos multi-room audio system. Not like Midday, a DIYer should purchase Good’s merchandise direct, although we skilled a number of set up complications throughout our evaluate (which, to be honest to Good, concerned pre-release {hardware}).

Greatest multi-function sensible dimmer

Simply what number of options are you able to cram in a single-gang gentle swap? Leviton squeezes a Wi-Fi radio, a dimmer swap, and a complete Amazon Alexa-compatible sensible speaker into its Decora Sensible Voice Wi-Fi Dimmer with Alexa. Sure, Ecobee pulled off the same trick earlier, however with an on/off swap, not a dimmer. Leviton additionally has deeper catalog of different Wi-Fi parts—switches, dimmers, ceiling fan controllers, multi-button controllers, and extra—to go together with it.

Greatest budget-priced sensible dimmer

Greatest recognized for constructing cheap routers, TP-Hyperlink has steadily elevated its footprint within the sensible residence area with its Kasa Sensible product line. Its mannequin HS-220 in-wall sensible dimmer connects on to your Wi-Fi community, so that you don’t want a hub, and it’s at the moment avenue priced lower than $20. One of many largest downsides? You possibly can’t use it in a three-way configuration.

On the following web page, we’ll give you useful ideas to bear in mind if you store for sensible lighting controls. Or are you able to click on right here to see our newest sensible dimmer critiques.

Sensible dimmer buying ideas

You’ll have to make a raft of selections earlier than you select which sensible switches to put in in your house, and your decisions will likely be influenced by every little thing from the kind of wiring in your partitions to what taste of sensible residence system you’ve now or plan to put in later. Right here’s what it’s good to know in roughly the order you’ll have to resolve.

Impartial wire requirement: The overwhelming majority of sensible switches and dimmers require the presence of a impartial wire—along with line (energy from the circuit-breaker panel), load (energy to the sunshine to be managed), and floor wires—within the electrical field contained in the wall. Sensible switches have radios that have to be consistently powered, and the impartial wire is what provides that juice. Whereas all houses have impartial wires, many older houses don’t have a impartial wire in each field. In the event you’re undecided if there’s a impartial wire on the location you wish to set up a sensible swap, we’ve a how-to story right here that may provide help to determine it out. In the event you don’t have a impartial wire, Lutron’s Caséta sensible dimmer is without doubt one of the few that does not require one.

c by ge smart switch without neutral wiring Ben Patterson/IDG

Most sensible switches rely upon the presence of a impartial wire to produce vitality to their radios, however many houses constructed previous to the Nineteen Eighties don’t have a impartial wire in each field. C by GE and Lutron Caséta are among the many few sensible switches that don’t rely a impartial wire.

Single- or multi-pole: If the sunshine you want to management is related to only one swap, you then’ll want to switch it with a single-pole sensible swap. If a couple of swap controls that load—switches on reverse sides of a room, for instance—you then’ll want to switch it with a multi-pole sensible swap. This usually implies that you’ll additionally want to purchase a companion swap or switches for the opposite finish(s) of the circuit. There are a number of exceptions to this rule, so test the documentation accompanying whichever sensible swap you resolve to purchase prior to installing it.

Management protocol: You’ll undoubtedly wish to management your sensible lighting together with your smartphone or pill, and most of the people may even wish to flip lights on and off with voice instructions spoken to a sensible speaker, comparable to an Amazon Echo or a Google Residence. However to do this, the sensible swap you purchase should have a way of connecting to your private home community (which explains why Bluetooth sensible switches can’t discuss to sensible audio system).

Some sensible switches join on to your Wi-Fi community, whereas others require a bridge to your router. In the event you’ve invested in a sensible residence system—Samsung SmartThings, Hubitat Elevation, Vivint Sensible Residence, or some other ecosystem—you’ll wish to ensure that the sensible swap you purchase is suitable with it. These are the most typical communication protocols you’ll encounter.

bluetooth logo Bluetooth SIG

Bluetooth This sort of sensible swap is managed immediately by an app in your smartphone or pill. Bluetooth sensible lighting is straightforward, since you don’t want a hub or a connection to your private home community. That isolation additionally makes it safe, since you have to be inside about 30 toes of the swap to pair with it. However, approved customers additionally have to be inside 30 toes of a Bluetooth swap to regulate it, and you may’t management the swap if you’re away from residence (though most Bluetooth switches could be managed in accordance with a pre-programmed schedule). The opposite main limitation of Bluetooth switches is that they’ll’t be managed by sensible audio system or sensible residence hubs, which usually depend on one of many different wi-fi protocols described right here.

lutron caseta logo Lutron

Lutron Clear Join This can be a proprietary wi-fi protocol utilized by Lutron Caséta Wi-fi sensible residence units, together with switches, dimmers, ceiling fan controllers, occupancy sensors, motorized shades, and battery-powered distant controls. You can even management a restricted variety of third-party units with Lutron’s app—starting from thermostats to Wi-Fi audio system—and incorporate them into sensible residence “scenes.” Clear Join operates independently of your Wi-Fi community, however you should hardwire a Lutron Sensible Bridge to your router to make use of it. You possibly can management Lutron Caséta units through Lutron’s app, with voice instructions spoken to sensible audio system, and from cellular units wherever you’ve broadband entry. Some sensible residence programs, together with Samsung SmartThings, may also incorporate Lutron’s sensible residence merchandise.

wifi logo Wi-Fi Alliance

Wi-Fi This can be a comparatively current development in sensible switches, in all probability as a result of Wi-Fi hasn’t all the time been the perfect technique of blanketing a house with connectivity. Mesh Wi-Fi routers, nonetheless, have gone an extended strategy to remedying that drawback. The attraction of Wi-Fi sensible switches is that they don’t require a hub or a bridge to hook up with your router. As soon as put in, they are often managed with sensible audio system, the producer’s personal app, and plenty of sensible residence programs (test compatibility before you purchase).

zwave plus Z-Wave Alliance

Z-Wave This can be a wi-fi mesh community expertise wherein every node on the community can also be a repeater that may ahead instructions on to different Z-Wave units close by. It operates within the unlicensed 800- to 900MHz radio spectrum (particularly, 908.42MHz in North America). Its low energy requirement means it may be included into battery-operated units that can not be plugged immediately into {an electrical} circuit, together with door/window sensors, sensible locks, water leak detectors, and movement sensors along with sensible dimmers and switches. You’ll want a sensible residence hub, comparable to a Samsung SmartThings, to behave as a bridge to your Wi-Fi community. Z-Wave is supported by a raft of sensible residence product builders, together with Leviton, Jasco, Aeotec, and others.

zigbee Zigbee Alliance

Zigbee This wi-fi mesh community expertise is similar to Z-Wave, but it surely operates within the unlicensed 2.4GHz radio spectrum (similar as single-band Wi-Fi). Like Z-Wave, Zigbee has a decrease energy requirement and could be included into each battery and line-powered units, starting from sensors to sensible switches. And as with Z-Wave, you’ll want a sensible residence hub or another sort of bridge to attach Zigbee units to your private home community. This could possibly be one thing so simple as an Amazon Echo Plus, which has an built-in Zigbee radio, or it could possibly be on the order of a Samsung SmartThings hub, which has each Zigbee and Z-Wave radios onboard.

lutron aurora smart bulb dimmer Lutron

As you may see on this illustration, it’s not essential to take away the duvet plate to put in the Aurora on the swap, but it surely solely works with toggle switches.

Signify’s Philips Hue bridge is one other answer, but it surely’s usually restricted to supporting Philips Hue sensible bulbs and equipment. Zigbee is extensively help amongst sensible dimmer producers, together with Jasco, Sinopé, and Sengled. Lutron additionally makes an ingenious Zigbee gadget for Philips Hue sensible bulbs—the Lutron Aurora—that attaches to an old school toggle gentle swap and never solely prevents the swap from being turned off (immediately rendering a Philips Hue sensible bulb dumb), but it surely wirelessly controls all of the Hub bulbs related to that swap—full with a rotary knob for dimming and brightening these bulbs and turning them on or off.

Swap mechanism: Since most individuals management sensible switches and dimmers with voice instructions, they quickly uncover that they hardly ever bodily work together with the units of their partitions. However you’ll wish to take into account the kind of mechanism the sensible swap makes use of if for no different motive than to make sure its aesthetic matches the remainder of your private home. These are the most typical sorts you’ll encounter.

typical toggle switch Michael Brown / IDG

Comparatively few producers make sensible switches that seem like this sort of old school toggle swap.

  • Rocker (aka paddle) This sort of swap has a large plastic panel that rocks forwards and backwards when pressed to show the managed load on and off (one aspect of the swap raises when the opposite is depressed). These modern-looking switches hug the wall and are very straightforward to function. Since a command issued over the air will override no matter bodily state the swap is in any other case in, sensible rocker switches usually don’t bodily flip, so there’s no confusion if you see a lit bulb when the swap is ostensibly within the “off” place. A sensible dimmer swap may need a secondary management—a vertical slider or a horizontal rocker—for adjusting brightness
  • Toggle A toggle swap operates by shifting a lever up and down (flipping the lever up turns the managed gentle on, and flipping it down turns it off). These kinds of switches are inclined to look extra old school than rocker switches, however you will discover sensible variations of them if you need one thing that appears like the opposite switches you’ve in your partitions. As with sensible rocker switches, they typically don’t utterly change bodily look when switched on or off.
  • Contact Excessive-end sensible switches and dimmers function touch-sensitive surfaces. Usually product of glass, touch-sensitive sensible switches and dimmers are usually backlit by a number of LEDs that may be a number of colours. The contact sensitivity could be so simple as contact to show the swap on and contact once more to show it off, or they are often as complicated as displaying a person interface that helps finger swipes for calling up totally different lighting scenes or management components. For sure, some of these sensible switches and dimmers value significantly greater than easy plastic units.
brilliant control b5 Christopher Null

Good’s touchscreen panel enables you to see and discuss with an individual at your door when a customer prompts your Ring Video Doorbell.

Wiring connections: Sensible switches and dimmers are usually bigger than their dumb counterparts, so you need to take into account how the brand new swap will slot in your present electrical field. That is notably necessary in the event you’re putting in a number of sensible switches subsequent to one another in a single field. Do not forget that there will likely be at the least 4 wires to take care of—line, load, impartial, and floor—and that there may even be a traveler wire in the event you’re coping with a multi-pole circuit. It may be difficult to stuff all these wires and the brand new swap again into the field. These are the most typical sorts of electrical connections you’ll encounter in sensible switches.

  • Backstabs These are holes behind the swap into which you’ll push (“stab”) the suitable strong copper wires popping out of the wall.
  • Pigtails Some switches have brief electrical wires rising from the again of the swap that you just’ll connect to the wires popping out of the wall, utilizing wire nuts to safe them. That is usually the best approach, but when the swap is deep, it may be a problem to pack the additional wires and the wire nuts tightly sufficient into the field in order that the swap mounts flush in opposition to the wall. It may be notably troublesome if the field has different units in it.
  • Terminals With this sort of swap, you’ll wind the wires popping out of the wall round flat screws on the edges of the swap after which tighten the screws down. This method presents much less of a problem in relation to pushing the wires and the swap again into the field, however the wires could be stiff and also you’ll should be cautious to make sure the stripped wire doesn’t come into contact with stripped wires related to adjoining switches within the field.
treatlife dimmer pigtails Christopher Null / IDG

Pigtails and wire nuts are one frequent strategy to join a sensible swap to your present in-wall wiring.

Our newest sensible swap critiques

Observe: While you buy one thing after clicking hyperlinks in our articles, we could earn a small fee. Learn our affiliate hyperlink coverage for extra particulars.