Vocal Nebula Assessment – Watch out for Paralysis By Evaluation

I’ve reviewed fairly a few on-line singing programs on the market, and I have to say – I’ve by no means seen one fairly like Vocal Nebula created by voice trainer Joe Naab. 

Briefly, I’ve blended emotions about this very distinctive singing course. As a result of as a voice trainer, Joe Naab actually opened my eyes along with his huge information of singing historical past and vocal methodology.

However, I’m afraid that the way in which he offered this vocal “coaching” program wouldn’t be an efficient one for the coaching of aspiring singers. 

On this Vocal Nebula evaluate, we’ll take an in-depth take a look at was is obtainable on this singing course, and I may even offer you my sincere opinion {and professional} evaluation in regards to the high quality of this vocal coaching product.

Who’s Joe Naab? Can he actually sing?

Whereas there’s not a lot info on the Web about Joe Naab – the founding father of Vocal Nebula, I did discovered that he has a background in Accounting and Funds and has been an entrepreneur for greater than 12 years.

Joe does have a Youtube channel for educating singing and demonstrating strategies by means of his personal singing. My utmost respect to voice academics who’ve the braveness to sing for his or her college students.

Let’s hear a little bit little bit of Joe Naab’s personal singing:

Not too unhealthy for a voice trainer!

I say that with a style of humor due to the variety of voice academics who can’t actually sing. It’s not even humorous!

From the restricted information I’ve of Joe’s background and the demo of his singing, I can inform that that is a person with a ardour for the artwork of singing!

Making a transition from Funds and Accounting to voice-teaching is one thing that takes zeal and enthusiasm for this artwork that we love so dearly.

When it comes to the examine of vocology, vocal historical past, and vocal methodology, Joe could be very educated and discovered.

It’s fascinating the knowledge he’s presenting on this singing course. 

Must know concept to sing effectively? No…

Most voice academics, together with myself, don’t know what Joe is aware of in regards to the historical past and methodology of singing. However, there’s a motive for this – you don’t have to know all these to be efficient as a voice trainer or singer.

In reality, I don’t encourage singers to study concept and vocal science at first of their coaching, since you simply don’t need to suppose an excessive amount of while you sing on stage!

The one voice trainer I do know that has efficiently offered sensible vocal science for singers to simply apply to their singing is grasp trainer John Henny.

Singing is about sensation – how your physique feels when you find yourself singing appropriately. That’s all we actually have to construct an incredible singing voice.

Now, you could be analytical when you find yourself educating singers, however you don’t need college students to be the identical method. I’m afraid that’s what college students would possibly expertise with Vocal Nebula.

What’s Inside Vocal Nebula?

If you log into the coaching platform of Vocal Nebula, you will note 4 primary programs masking the key areas of vocal coaching that covers the idea of voice constructing, breath coaching, vocal manufacturing, vowel shaping, and so on.

Inside every primary programs, there are completely different coaching modules that comprise video classes with Joe Naab lecturing and demonstrating his strategies.

The lesson content material and supplies offered within the modules are very in depth. Joe explains his strategies very completely…and a little bit bit too thorough and detailed together with the feeling of the vocal workout routines, historic quotes from nice(lifeless) singers from the previous, vocal science, and so on.

Apart from Joe’s very in depth lectures and classes, there’s a very user-friendly audio playlist of vocal scales for college students to follow with.

These audio tracks are very simple to comply with and tailor-made for, not simply female and male singers, however low, center, and excessive voices. 

I’ve seen many on-line singing programs through the years. Not many coaching platforms have audio playlist for college students’ vocal follow as full and detailed because the one on Vocal Nebula.

Is the Vocal Technique being taught appropriate?

The vocal strategies being taught at Vocal Nebula are principally protected and proper, such because the idea of Voice Constructing – some voice academics don’t consider it’s essential really construct a voice in a singer, coaching learn how to breathe for singing, and the adjusting the vowels and resonant areas. 

One thing that the majority voice academics and singers don’t do is READ about singing – one thing Joe clearly does very extensively.

I really admire Joe about that. In any case, the nice singing traditions from the previous are previous down in writing. Enrico Caruso, Luisa Tetrazzini, William Vennard, and plenty of different nice singers and academics all wrote books to coach singers in regards to the artwork of singing. 

The issue is – it is extremely arduous to learn to sing from studying, particularly from studying previous literature from the previous. (They did write otherwise again then, which makes it more durable to know.)

I learn books and articles about singing, however simply sufficient to get me the solutions I would like for singing.

What I don’t like about Vocal Nebula

1. An excessive amount of speaking about singing.

Joe jogs my memory of my music professor Matt again in faculty. Matt talks an excessive amount of about singing and concept in our voice classes.

I nonetheless bear in mind standing by means of our voice classes pondering, “When are we going to sing?” This maestro talked and sang greater than I did in our classes.

In an effort to write a good evaluate, I needed to actually pressure myself to take a seat by means of and watch each lesson on Vocal Nebula.

Let me inform you- it will get actually boring after a few classes, and there are lots of classes right here.

2. Ineffective vocal coaching.

I really feel actually unhealthy about pointing this out, nevertheless it’s true. The voice trainer is meant to be a coach guiding the singer by means of vocal workout routines and difficult them to follow constantly.

The identical holds true with on-line singing programs as effectively. Though you can not see the scholars, you are able to do your finest to information the scholars by means of the workout routines. 

The purpose is – singing is a bodily exercise or sport, not a cognitive one. 

There’s nothing unsuitable with what’s being taught on Vocal Nebula. I simply suppose the “coaching type” will not be an efficient one.

It’s like studying learn how to play golf by studying a guide or sitting by means of lectures.

For singing, you really want to be taught by doing!

3. Unscripted classes.

It’s protected to concluded that many of the classes aren’t scripted, which I consider is essential for a course like this, particularly in case you’re not too skilled educating singing in entrance of the digicam.

Scripting classes is crucial for high quality management. With out scripts, you’re simply improvising with a lesson define. The academics could be rambling, and the teachings would possibly change into very draggy.

Brett Manning initially wrote 400 pages of lesson scripts for the manufacturing of the Singing Success program. If Brett Manning needed to do it, we voice academics ought to be taught from him.

The Execs and Cons of Vocal Nebula

I’ve offered my primary evaluation and critique of this singing program. I respect Joe Naab for his information and fervour for the artwork of singing. 

Execs

• The teacher is educated in vocology and singing historical past.
• Protected and sound vocal methodology.
• Full audio playlist offered for singing.
• Good for knowledgeable singers/academics within the science and concept of singing.

Cons

• An excessive amount of speaking about singing.
• Ineffective vocal coaching.
• Unscripted classes a little bit bit draggy at occasions.

Conclusion

I consider there’s arduous work and nice effort concerned within the manufacturing of this singing course, and I salute Joe Naab for that. Nevertheless, there’s enchancment to be made to the coaching curriculum.

I’m afraid this course is, at finest, good for knowledgeable singers or voice academics within the physiology, science, and historical past of singing.

Should you simply need to practice your voice, or in case you simply need to “do it,” this course might be NOT for you.

In conclusion, I don’t advocate this singing course for inexperienced persons and even intermediate singers.

When you’ve got any query, remark under. I’ll be completely satisfied to debate with you.

Glad singing,

Rex 

​